Rates of Joint Replacements and Neck of Femur (NOF) fractures are rapidly increasing due to an ageing population, thus placing an increasing demand on Rehabilitation Services.
We conducted this retrospective study to investigate how pain at rest
and on movement (documented on admission), type of operation (hip/
knee replacement vs neck of femur fracture), age, gender and admission
Functional Independence Measure (FIM) total score impacted on Length
of Stay (LOS).
The cohort comprised all consecutive patients admitted to a Victorian Rehabilitation Hospital post Fractured NOF, Elective Total Hip and Total Knee Replacement surgery from 6 February 2012 – 6 June 2012.
The sample comprised 63 patients, predominantly female (54 or 85.7%), aged from 48-96 years (mean=74, sd=11.1). LOS ranged from 2-49 days (mean=17.2, sd=9.5). Multiple regression examined all 6 variables simultaneously. A contemporary variable selection method, known as LASSO regression, searched for key variables by attempting to shrink less important regression coefficients towards zero. The main outcome measure in this study length of stay. No interventions were used in this study.
The full regression model of 6 variables accounted for 65.3% variation in LOS, however, LASSO regression selected 3 variables which accounted for 62.9% of variation in LOS, there being no statistically significant loss of performance with the smaller model. The 3 variables were admission FIM, operation type, and pain on movement. Increased admission FIM and knee or hip replacement were associated with shorter LOS, Neck of Femur fracture and increased pain on movement were associated with longer LOS.
Given the increased demand on rehabilitation beds, predicting length of
stay using the 3 key markers identified in this study may help to optimise
List of Abbreviations: FIM – Functional Independence Measure; LASSO – Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator; LOS – Length of Stay; NOF – Neck of Femur Fractures; NRS – Numerical Rating Scale
Rates of Joint Replacements and Neck of Femur (NOF) fractures are
increasing due to an ageing population, thus placing an increasing
demand on Rehabilitation Services.
This amount of hospital resource utilization calls for a greater understanding of the key factors associated with hospital Length of Stay (LOS) to ensure efficient provision of health services .
Currently, however, there is little research available to guide clinicians about factors influencing Length of Stay (LOS) in inpatient Orthopaedic Rehabilitation. The authors of this paper were unable to find research to guide which factors influence Length of Stay in this patient population.
A recent study looked at acute LOS following knee arthroplasty . It was found that patients with a long LOS were older, had lower pre-operative range of knee flexion and had greater knee pain than patients with a short LOS. Our study extends the above study by predicting LOS in a Rehabilitation setting, as well as by employing contemporary methods of variable selection to identify key predictors.
To investigate how the variables listed in Table 1 impacted on Length of Stay (LOS) in inpatient Orthopaedic Rehabilitation via a retrospective study.
The cohort comprised of all consecutive patients admitted to a Victorian
Rehabilitation Hospital post Fractured NOF, Elective Total Hip and Total
Knee Replacement surgery, from 6 February 2012 – 6 June 2012.
Information was obtained from case notes. Case notes were obtained from
Case notes were examined and information gathered on: documented Admission and Discharge FIM scores, documented pain score at the time of admission on movement and at rest using the Numerical Rating Scale (NRS). Information about Patients’ demographic data namely age, gender and type of surgery was also gathered from case notes. During the 4 month period, 86 patients were admitted for rehabilitation post NOF surgery and Total Hip and Knee Replacement to the ward.
The outcome of interest in this study is Length of Stay in Patients admitted for Orthopaedic Rehabilitation. Six variables representing questions that should be routinely documented when a patient is admitted for rehabilitation post-surgery were chosen to see how they impacted on patients’ LOS. The six variables consisted of age in years, female gender (yes/no), FIM total score on admission, whether hip/knee replacement or NOF fracture, 10-point pain score at rest and 10-point pain score on movement.
Of the 86 patients, two (2.3%) had a missing FIM score, 14 (16.3%) were missing pain at rest score, and 19 (22.1%) were missing pain at movement score. No other information was missing. Due to the small sample size, missing observations were handled using complete-case analysis. 63 (73.3%) patients had complete information on the six predictor variables listed above as well as length of hospital stay, and so formed the analytic sample. Patients were predominantly female (54 or 85.7%), and had undergone knee or hip replacement surgery (43 or 68.2%). The 63 patients were aged from 48-96 years (mean=74, standard deviation (sd)=11.1). LOS ranged from 2-49 days (mean=17.2, sd=9.5), admission FIM from 23-113 (mean=82.7, sd=18.4), pain at rest from 0-10 (mean=3.5, sd=2.6) and pain on movement ranged from 0-10, (mean=6.6, sd=2.6).
Ethics approval for this study was granted by the Eastern Health Human Research Ethics Committee (LR 94/1112).
Multiple regression was initially employed to examine all 6 variables
simultaneously. Models containing a small number of variables are
generally easier to interpret, yet often perform comparably to more
complex models [3,4,5]. A contemporary variable selection method,
known as LASSO (Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator)
regression , was therefore used to search for key variables by attempting
to shrink regression coefficients towards zero, down-weighting less
important predictors. As a model developed on one sample of patients may
not generalize well to another sample , LASSO implements a method
of internal validation known as k-fold cross-validation to maximize
generalizability of its models. The sample is randomly divided into 10
subsamples and models developed on 9/10 subsamples are tested on the
held-out 10th subsample, with each subsample being held-out in turn .
LASSO has recently been applied in rehabilitation medicine [7,8,9].
All statistical analyses were performed using SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute Incorporated, Cary, North Carolina, 2014).
As shown in Table 1, higher pain at rest and pain on movement, and older
age were associated with longer length of stay, although none of these
associations was statistically significant.
Conversely, having a hip or knee replacement rather than a NOF fracture surgery, being female and having a higher admission total Functional Independence (FIM) Score was associated with shorter length of stay, e.g., each 10-point increase in Admission FIM was associated with a reduced LOS of two days. All of the associations with shorter length of stay, apart from that for female gender, were statistically significant.
The full model of six variables accounted for 65.3% of the variation in LOS.
Three variables with non-zero regression coefficients were selected by LASSO, using cross-validation as described earlier. These three variables, type of operation, admission FIM and pain on movement together accounted for 62.9% of the variation in LOS, only slightly less than that accounted for by all six predictors. A likelihood ratio test10 showed that there was no statistically significant difference in overall performance between the six and three predictor models, (p=0.24).
Regression on log-transformed LOS, as employed in a recent knee arthroplasty study  accounted for 56.9% and 55.7% of the variation in LOS, for six and three predictor models respectively, the difference in overall performance not being statistically significant (p=0.65).
Given the increased demand on rehabilitation services, predicting length
of stay using Admission FIM, Operation Type and Immediate Release
Pain Medication and Pain on Movement may help optimize resource
allocation and potentially ensure a smooth discharge planning process.
Our study focused on post-operative variables and included admission FIM scores after common orthopaedic procedures (hip/knee replacement and NOF fracture) most commonly requiring rehabilitation services . Although confirmation in larger populations is required, length of stay in inpatient orthopaedic rehabilitation appears to be satisfactorily predicted using a simple model comprising three readily obtainable post-operative variables.
- Halawi MJ, Vovos TJ, Green CL, Wellman SS, Attarian DE, et al.(2015) Preoperative pain level and patient expectation predict hospital length of stay after total hip arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty 30(4): 555-558.
- Ong PH, Pua YH (2013) A prediction model for length of stay aftertotal and unicompartmental knee replacement. Bone Joint J 95: 1490-1496.
- Gigerenzer G (2015) Simply rational: decision making in the real world. New York: Oxford University Press.
- McKenzie DP, Toumbourou JW, Forbes AB, Mackinnon AJ, McMorris BJ, et al. (2011) Predicting future depression in adolescents using the short mood and feelings questionnaire: a twonation study. J Affect Disord 134(1-3): 151-159.
- Hastie T, Tibshirani R (2015) Statistical learning with sparsity: theLASSO and generalizations. Boca Raton, Florida: Chapman and Hall.
- Harrell FE (2015) Regression modeling strategies: with applicationto linear models, logistic regression and survival analysis. New York: Springer.
- Tighe PJ, Harle CA, Hurley RW, Aytug H, Boezaart AP, et al. (2015)Teaching a machine to feel postoperative pain: combining highdimensionalclinical data with machine learning algorithms to forecast postoperative pain. Pain Med 16(7): 1386 – 1401.
- Prodinger B, Cieza A, Oberhauser C, Bickenbach J, Ustun TB, etal. (2016) Toward the international classification of functioning, disability and health (ICF) rehabilitation set: A minimal generic set of domains for rehabilitation as a health strategy. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 97(6): 875-874.
- Del Felice A, Bargellesi S, Linassi F, Scarpa B, Formaggio E, etal. (2017) The potential role of pain-related SSEP’s in the early prognostication of long-term functional outcome in post-anoxic coma. Eur J Phys Rehabil Med 53(6): 883-891.
- Herbold JA, Bonistall K, Walsh MB (2011) Rehabilitation followingtotal knee replacement, total hip replacement and hip fracture: a case-controlled comparison. J Geriatr Phys Ther 34(4): 155-160